Patient Abandonment – Home Health Care

My Blog

Elements of the Cause of Action for Abandonment

Each of the subsequent 5 factors have to be gift for a patient to have a proper civil cause of movement for the tort of abandonment:

1. Health care treatment changed into unreasonably discontinued.

2. The termination of wellness coach care changed into contrary to the patient’s will or with out the patient’s know-how.

Three. The health care provider did not set up for care by using every other appropriate skilled fitness care company.

Four. The fitness care provider must have fairly foreseen that damage to the affected person might get up from the termination of the care (proximate cause).

5. The affected person definitely suffered harm or loss due to the discontinuance of care.

Physicians, nurses, and other fitness care professionals have an moral, in addition to a criminal, responsibility to avoid abandonment of sufferers. The health care expert has a responsibility to provide his or her patient all important interest so long as the case required it and should now not leave the affected person in a important level without giving affordable note or making suitable arrangements for the attendance of some other. [2]

Abandonment with the aid of the Physician

When a health practitioner undertakes remedy of a patient, remedy have to maintain until the affected person’s situations not warrant the treatment, the doctor and the patient jointly consent to stop the treatment by means of that health practitioner, or the affected person discharges the medical doctor. Moreover, the health practitioner can also unilaterally terminate the connection and withdraw from treating that patient best if she or he affords the affected person right note of his or her motive to withdraw and an opportunity to reap right substitute care.

In the home fitness putting, the health practitioner-patient relationship does no longer terminate simply due to the fact a patient’s care shifts in its region from the hospital to the house. If the patient continues to need clinical offerings, supervised health care, remedy, or other domestic fitness services, the attending doctor have to ensure that she or he was nicely discharged his or her-obligations to the patient. Virtually each situation ‘wherein domestic care is accredited by means of Medicare, Medicaid, or an insurer might be one wherein the patient’s ‘wishes for care have continued. The doctor-affected person relationship that existed inside the hospital will retain except it’s been officially terminated with the aid of be aware to the patient and an affordable try and refer the affected person to every other suitable health practitioner. Otherwise, the doctor will retain his or her responsibility in the direction of the patient when the affected person is discharged from the health facility to the home. Failure to comply with thru at the part of the physician will represent the tort of abandonment if the patient is injured as a result. This abandonment may additionally disclose the physician, the clinic, and the house fitness employer to liability for the tort of abandonment.

The attending doctor in the sanatorium ought to make sure that a right referral is made to a physician who could be answerable for the house fitness patient’s care while it’s far being added by using the home health issuer, until the health practitioner intends to preserve to supervise that domestic care personally. Even extra vital, if the health center-primarily based health practitioner arranges to have the affected person’s care assumed through some other medical doctor, the affected person have to fully apprehend this transformation, and it should be carefully documented.

As supported by case regulation, the varieties of movements with a view to result in legal responsibility for abandonment of a patient will consist of:

• premature discharge of the patient through the physician

• failure of the doctor to offer proper commands earlier than discharging the patient

• the declaration by the doctor to the affected person that the medical doctor will now not treat the patient

• refusal of the physician to respond to calls or to in addition attend the patient

• the doctor’s leaving the affected person after surgical operation or failing to observe up on postsurgical care. [3]

Generally, abandonment does no longer occur if the physician accountable for the affected person arranges for a replacement doctor to take his or her vicinity. This exchange may also occur because of holidays, relocation of the physician, infection, distance from the affected person’s domestic, or retirement of the physician. As long as care through an correctly skilled physician, sufficiently knowledgeable of the affected person’s unique situations, if any, has been organized, the courts will usually now not discover that abandonment has befell. [4] Even in which a patient refuses to pay for the care or is unable to pay for the care, the physician isn’t at liberty to terminate the connection unilaterally. The health practitioner must still take steps to have the patient’s care assumed by way of some other [5] or to offer a sufficiently affordable time frame to locate every other prior to ceasing to offer care.

Although most of the instances mentioned problem the medical doctor-patient relationship, as mentioned formerly, the identical ideas apply to all health care vendors. Furthermore, because the care rendered with the aid of the house fitness organisation is supplied pursuant to a doctor’s plan of care, despite the fact that the affected person sued the doctor for abandonment because of the movements (or inactions of the home health business enterprise’s group of workers), the doctor may additionally seek indemnification from the house fitness company. [6]


Similar concepts to those who observe to physicians follow to the home fitness expert and the house health issuer. A home fitness company, because the direct provider of care to the homebound affected person, can be held to the identical prison duty and responsibility to supply care that addresses the patient’s wishes as is the physician. Furthermore, there can be each a prison and an moral duty to continue turning in care, if the patient has no options. An ethical responsibility can also nonetheless exist to the affected person despite the fact that the house fitness company has fulfilled all prison responsibilities. [7]

When a domestic fitness provider furnishes remedy to a affected person, the duty to continue offering care to the patient is a duty owed by using the organization itself and now not via the person expert who can be the employee or the contractor of the organization. The home fitness issuer does now not have a responsibility to continue offering the identical nurse, therapist, or aide to the patient at some point of the course of remedy, as long as the issuer keeps to use suitable, capable employees to administer the route of treatment always with the plan of care. From the perspective of patient delight and continuity of care, it could be inside the exceptional pastimes of the home fitness provider to try to offer the identical individual practitioner to the patient. The development of a non-public courting with the provider’s personnel may also enhance communications and a extra degree of consider and compliance at the a part of the patient. It need to assist to relieve a few of the troubles that rise up inside the fitness care’ placing.

If the affected person requests substitute of a selected nurse, therapist, technician, or home fitness aide, the house health provider still has a duty to offer care to the patient, until the affected person also especially states she or he no longer dreams the company’s provider. Home fitness organization supervisors need to usually comply with up on such patient requests to determine the reasons regarding the dismissal, to come across “hassle” employees, and to ensure no incident has taken area that could provide upward thrust to liability. The domestic fitness corporation should preserve presenting care to the patient until definitively told not to achieve this through the patient.


Home health issuer employees can also on occasion stumble upon an abusive affected person. This abuse mayor won’t be a result of the scientific condition for which the care is being furnished. Personal protection of the character health care provider ought to be paramount. Should the affected person pose a physical threat to the man or woman, he or she need to go away the premises right away. The company need to record within the medical report the facts surrounding the incapacity to finish the treatment for that visit as objectively as possible. Management personnel should inform supervisory employees at the house fitness company and need to complete an inner incident report. If it appears that a crook act has taken place, which include a physical attack, tried rape, or other such act, this act need to be stated at once to neighborhood law enforcement organizations. The home care provider need to additionally without delay notify both the patient and the health practitioner that the provider will terminate its courting with the patient and that an opportunity issuer for those offerings should be acquired.

Other much less critical situations may also, nonetheless, lead the home fitness issuer to determine that it must terminate its dating with a selected affected person. Examples may consist of especially abusive sufferers, patients who solicit -the house health issuer professional to interrupt the regulation (for example, by using imparting unlawful drugs or presenting non-covered offerings and equipment and billing them as something else), or consistently noncompliant sufferers. Once remedy is undertaken, but, the home fitness issuer is usually obliged to retain presenting offerings till the affected person has had an inexpensive opportunity to achieve a alternative issuer. The same concepts apply to failure of a affected person to pay for the offerings or device provided.

As fitness care experts, HHA employees have to have schooling on a way to manage the difficult patient responsibly. Arguments or emotional remarks need to be averted. If it becomes clear that a certain provider and affected person aren’t in all likelihood to be like minded, a substitute issuer must be attempted. Should it appear that the hassle lies with the affected person and that it is necessary for the HHA to terminate its dating with the patient, the subsequent seven steps ought to be taken:

1. The instances ought to be documented in the affected person’s record.

2. The home fitness provider need to provide or send a letter to the affected person explaining the occasions surrounding the termination of care.

3. The letter ought to be despatched with the aid of certified mail, go back receipt requested, or different measures to record patient receipt of the letter. A replica of the letter should be positioned in the patient’s file.

4. If viable, the affected person need to be given a certain period of time to acquire replacement care. Usually 30 days is sufficient.

Five. If the affected person has a existence-threatening circumstance or a medical circumstance that could become worse within the absence of persevering with care, this situation ought to be virtually stated in the letter. The necessity of the affected person’s obtaining replacement home fitness care should be emphasised.

6. The patient must be informed of the region of the nearest sanatorium emergency branch. The patient should be told to either visit the closest health facility emergency branch in case of a medical emergency or to call the nearby emergency quantity for ambulance transportation.

7. A replica of the letter should be sent to the patient’s attending doctor thru certified mail, return receipt asked.

These steps ought to no longer be undertaken lightly. Before such steps are taken, the patient’s case must be very well discussed with the house fitness company’s threat manager, prison suggest, scientific director, and the affected person’s attending physician.

The inappropriate discharge of a affected person from health care insurance by way of the home health issuer, whether or not because of termination of entitlement, incapacity to pay, or other reasons, might also lead to legal responsibility for the tort of abandonment. [8]

Nurses who passively stand by using and examine negligence by way of a doctor or all of us else will individually turn out to be accountable to the patient who’s injured as a result of that negligence… [H]ealthcare centers and their nursing body of workers owe an independent responsibility to sufferers beyond the responsibility owed via physicians. When a doctor’s order to discharge is irrelevant, the nurses may be help answerable for following an order that they knew or must know is under the usual of care. [9]

Similar standards may additionally follow to make the house fitness issuer vicariously liable, as well.

Liability to the patient for the tort of abandonment may end result from the home fitness care expert’s failure to have a look at, take a look at, assess, or screen a patient’s situation. [10] Liability for abandonment can also arise from failing to take well timed movement, in addition to failing to summon a physician while a medical doctor is wanted. [11] Failing to offer good enough body of workers to meet the affected person’s needs may additionally represent abandonment at the part of the HHA. [12] Ignoring a affected person’s proceedings and failing to comply with a health practitioner’s orders might also likewise constitute a tort of abandonment for a nurse or different professional group of workers member.

1. Lee v. Dewbre, 362 S.W.2d 900 (Tex. Civ. App. 7th Dist. 1962).

2. Kattsetos v. Nolan, 368 A.2nd 172 (Conn. 1976).

Three. 61 AM. Jur. 2d, Physicians and Surgeons § 237 (1981).

Four. See, e.G., Tripp v. Pate, 271 S.E.2d 407 (N.C. App. 1980).

Five. Ricks v. Budge, 64 P.2d 208 (Utah 1937).

6. M.D. Nathanson, Home Healthcare Answer Book: Legal Issues for Providers 212 (1995).

7. See, usually, E.P. Burnzeig, The Nurse’s Liability for Malpractice (1981).

Eight. Sheryl Feutz-Harter, Nursing Caselaw Update: In appropriate Discharging of Patients, 2 J. Nursing L. Forty nine (1995).

Nine. Id., 53.

10. See, e.G., Pisel v. Stamford Hosp., 430 A.2d1 (Conn. 1980) (nurses had been held responsible for failing to monitor the situation of a patient).

11. See, e.G., Sanchez v. Bay General Hosp., 172 Cal. Rptr. 342 (Cal. App. 1981); Valdez v. Lyman-Roberts Hosp., Inc. 638 S.W. 2d 111 (Tex. 1982).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *